Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Causes of Great Depression

Hi Fellow Scholars,

We've been reading various interpretations on the causes of the Great Depression, and we've been evaluating them by asking how well they connect to the depression (decline in GDP and high unemployment) and whether we see what we should see if this is a cause. Now we're going to have a discussion about three of these interpretations: 1. Monetary causes (gold standard/Federal Reserve Bank policies), 2. International trade, 3. unequal distribution of wealth. How strong are each of these as causes? You can comment on any one of them. Have fun!

60 comments:

  1. First! Haha just kidding... I think that the unequal distribution of wealth was the most important cause of the Depression. We see this pattern in other instances in history as well. Recently, with unequal distribution of wealth in the United States, a recession resulted. When there is unequal distribution of wealth and the poor keep getting poorer, people are going to stop buying things, stop borrowing money, and prices are going to go way down. They economy slows down if only a small percentage of the country has money.

    -Emily Tanch

    ReplyDelete
  2. Although I can understand why some historians say that that international trade and unequal distribution of wealth are major causes of the Great Depression, I think that monetary causes (gold standard and Federal Reserve) were the main contributors of the Great Depression. I think it is important to understand that there if monetary factors did contribute to the Great Depression we should see this in other countries, and we do. For example those countries that had remained on the gold standard the longest had the longest depression (France, Poland, Belgium, Netherlands, Italy). Those countries that got off the gold standard the soonest (Spain, Sweden, Britain, and their trading powers) got out of the depression the soonest. After the class discussion we came to the conclusion that we couldn't find may faults in monetary causes. One being that the country had been on the gold standard for many years before- so why hadn't this happened sooner? I also think that the decisions of the Federal Reserve were influenced by the issues with the gold standard. I think that the gold standard and the poor decisions of the Federal Reserve in response to the gold standard in combination contributed to the stock crash and the Great Depression. Although in my opinion the main cause was monetary and Federal Reserve's action, there were also other causes mentioned that were influential, but not to the degree that monetary causes were on the Great Depression

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't believe that unequal distribution of wealth is a good cause because this unequalness is always there. In every society there are the poor and the rich, therefore always having unequal distribution of wealth. This is like the gravity cause it is always there so it can't be a cause. If this were a cause why didn't we see a depression earlier, or in other countries with unequal wealth. This might have been an amplifier in the depression because the wealth gap was so large. But this solely alone did not cause the great depression, but it might have made the depression last longer and put it on the magnitude the depression was on.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with Julia. It was monetary causes like the gold standard and the Federal Reserve Bank policies that caused the Great Depression. As a result of the gold standard, the United States had 70 percent of the total gold supply. In order to prevent more money from entering the United States, interest rates were low. However, this caused stock speculation. In response, the Federal Reserve Bank raised interest rates to stop the outflow of gold. This caused to a slowdown in the economy. Therefore, the Federal Reserve Bank,raised interest rates again, which slowed the economy and caused the Great Depression. Furthermore it was the gold standard and the Federal Reserve policies that led to the Great Depression.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think that the monetary problems were the main cause of the Great Depression. Because the United States had 70% of the world's gold supply, the government lowered the interests in order to prevent more money from entering the country. The sudden drop in interest rates led to the stock market crash. When the Federal Reserve bank raised the interest rates in an effort to repair the economy, the economy actually slowed and eventually turned into a depression. I don't think that unequal distribution of wealth and international trade are strong causes of the Great Depression. If unequal distribution of wealth was a cause of the depression then we should see depressions occurring whenever there is an unequal distribution of wealth, and we don't. As Rachel mentioned, this is a "gravity" cause. There is always going to be an equal distribution of money. There is always going to be a rich class and poor class but this does not always lead to a depression. Foreign trade problems are not a strong cause of the Great Depression either. As we learned in class, foreign trade was only 2-3% of the United States' income. During the Great Depression, the country's GDP dropped 36%. Even if foreign trade problems were the main cause of the depression, the GDP would have only dropped 2-3%, not 36%.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Before class today, I thought that the unequal distribution of wealth was the main cause for the Great Depression. Since the upper class had so much money, they were able to invest it in business. But the lower classes did not have any money to buy what was being produced by these businesses, causing overproduction.

    After our discussion in class today, I'm more tempted to say that the gold standard was the major cause of the depression. The US rocked the gold standard, being the country with the most gold to back up their money. So interests rates were lowered and that caused people to FLIP out and speculate about the stock market. They sold their stocks rapidly and caused the market to essentially crash.

    It's hard trying to determine what the main cause of something is, especially when it seems like all the causes kind of cause each other. But this is what makes history so awesome!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Before, and even during our class discussion yesturday I chose that the monetary (gold standard/Federal Reserve Bank policies), were the main cause of the Great Depression. A big factor as to why I chose it to be a main cause is because other countries that we know of have also picked up the gold standard, suffered from depressions also, and countires that sooner took themselves off the gold standard, had a earlier recovery than those that did not. There is an unequal distribution of wealth everywhere, bu we do not see depressiosns breaking out everywhere. Also, problems with international trade are always occuring with countires, but it does not create something as big as a depression to occur, especially since like Sarah mentioned, it only made up 2-3% of our GDP. The reason why the it caused a Great depression is because we, as a country, held 7o% of the worlds gold, which created an overflow of currency. The U.S decided to lower interest rates to prevent more money from flowing in. But then a stock speculation occured and the U.S decided to raise interest rates to stop the flow of gold from leaving the country. In response to banks raisnig taxes, the econonmy slowed down, causing a depression to occur.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I also think that monetary (gold standard/Federal Reserve Bank policies) causes were the strongest causes. The Gold Standard not only affected the US, but other countries as well. In Mr. O'Reilly's notes from Ben Bernanke, he says that "those countries that stayed on the gold standard longest had the longest depressions...those that got off the gold standard soonest got out of the depression soonest." The Federal Reserve's poor decisions amplified the Depression's effects to far worse than what they could have been. Had the interest rates not been raised twice, people might have been more willing to invest, etc. Unequal distribution of wealth did not contribute to the Depression as much as the Feds; if the interest rates hadn't been raised, poorer people would still have spent money and kept the economy going.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Before our class discussion about the main cause of the great depression I thought the main cause was the stock crashes. I thought they were what kept the economy in a downward slope until it reached a full blown depression.

    After we had a couple of classes discussing the causes of the depression and I was able to hear other people's views I now think the main cause was the runs on the banks. The runs on the banks causes for more then half of the United States banks to close. This left people with losing their money and no more money to flow into the economy. That declines the GDP and raises the unemployment.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Before our class discussion I thought that the unequal distribution of wealth was the main cause of the depression. I still think that the unequal distribution of wealth was a factor and had an impact on the depression but I think that the main cause of the Great Depression was also the gold standard and the Federal Reserve policies. The gold standard cause the interest rates to be low because the U.S. had too much gold so they had to keep interest rates low. Then the Federal Reserve made the mistake of raising interest rates twice. With each of these policies the economy got worse and the rapid switch from low interest rates to high interest rates cause a depression because these policies also led to the stock market crash. Also many other countries that were on the gold standard had weak economies and chose to lose the gold standard.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I don't believe that unequal distribution of wealth is a "good" cause because unequal distribution of wealth occurs everywhere in the world, no matter what circumstances are. Rich and poor always exists, it is inevitable. If this was a cause of the great depression, then why don't we see depression in other countries with unequal wealth (a.k.a. everywhere). This may be a cause, but it is not the most important or most comprehend-able cause. This may have affected the scale of the depression or it's time span but it is still not that important of a cause. In my opinion, runs on the banks were the most important cause.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I agree with everything here that has been said; unequal distribution of wealth is not a relevant cause-- if it was, where are all the other Great Depressions wherever else there is this inequality? Before yesterday's class, I actually did believe that this was a big factor. Now, I see that monetary reasons (gold standard/ Federal Reserve Bank policies) were actually more important, because high interest rates scared people into taking money out of the system. In the government's attempt to keep gold in the country, it actually contracted the money supply, and this contraction is what caused the 25% unemployment and so on.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Before our class discussion I thought the main cause of the Great Depression was the stock crash. After our discussion however, I now think that the gold standard/Federal reserve bank policy was the main cause of the depression. The Gold Standard was put in place to prevent countries from printing out to much money thus causing inflation. The Gold Standard however caused large amounts of money to come into the US. In order to prevent more money from entering interests rates were lowered which then led to stock speculation. Then in 1928 the Federal Reserve Bank raised interest rates to stop the outflow of gold. This led to a slowdown in the economy. In 1931 the Federal Reserve Bank raised interest rates again because they were concerned about the outflow of gold. In doing this they slowed the economy down dramatically. That’s what I think the main cause of the depression is.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I had never thought the unequal distribution of wealth was a cause of the Depression because wealth is never equally distributed in a country. I had however underestimated the huge impact of the gold standard, and later the raising of the interest rates. I now believe that it was the decrease in the money supply as a result of the gold standard and people taking money out of circulation which is what really caused it. When the people got scared of the banks and kept their money in a "coffee can" or wherever they kept it, that money was no longer circulating through the economy which hurt it. This is what caused the recession, and then the increase in the interest rates made people really not want to buy which led to overproduction, unemployment, lower GDP, and turned that recession into the Great Depression.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Before our class discussion I thought the main cause of the Great Depression was the run on banks. However, I now believe that the main cause is the poor policies of the Federal Reserve and the Gold Standard. The Federal Reserve made three horrible decisions that led to the Depression. First they decided to raise the interest rates in order to protect the gold which caused a recession to begin. Then the Federal Reserve decided to raise interest rates again in order to save the gold from flowing out of the country. This caused the bad economic situation to increase. The third poor policy was the Federal Reserve decided not to help the failing banks. All three of these decisions contributed to the failing economy because they caused the citizens and businesses to stop taking out loans and depositing money into the banks. As a result the money supply decreased and many become unemployed; therefore, causing a depression.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I completely agree with Dani. There is always inequality between classes, but beyond that, there is different amount of inequality in different societies, meaning that if another society with the same amount of inequality doesn't fall into a perpetual depression, then it is unlikely that this is a cause.
    It was very difficult for me to decide between the decisions of the Federal Reserve and the runs on banks as what I thought was the most important cause. In the end, I decided that the runs on banks were most important. I thought that both were important, however the runs on banks have many connections to the Depression (meaning that there were many possible ways to affect the economy and the country)rather than just one connection. Also, one of the Federal Reserve's biggest mistakes was raising taxes not once, but twice. When banks are hurting because of the runs on banks, they need more investment to offset the withdrawls. One way of doing this is through raising interest rates, making investment seem more beneficial. The Federal Reserve made some horrible decisions, but they could have been caused by a hurt in the banks themselves. Another poor decision by the Federal Reserve was to not help out banks directly by funding them, this would not have been an issue without the failing of the banks.
    Overall, the failing of the banks (due to the runs on the banks) caused the Depression as it jumpstarted the spiral of the economy, and the multiple poor decisions made by the Federal Reserve.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Like Cristi, I also didn't think much of the monetary causes (gold standard/Federal Reserve Bank Policies) as important as the unequal distribution of wealth. After the class discussion and reading various comments here I now see that the gold standard, which led to a contraction on the money supply, is indeed an important cause to the Great Depression. As stock speculation was increasing and the flow of gold was leaving the US, the Federal Reserve Bank increased interest rates. This created a stock market panic, where everyone was pulling out their investments and resulted in the stock market crash. Then when the Federal Reserve Bank raised interest rates AGAIN, this led to an even worse economic situation. This ultimately resulted in a decrease in GDP since people weren't investing in the economy by not buying goods and running to the banks to withdraw their savings. As consumption went down, companies had to fire workers, and this led to higher unemployment.
    Many critics say that the Federal Reserve Bank raising interest rates for a second time was the fatal flaw which led to the Great Depression, and I have to agree with them. With higher interest rates, more and more businesses would be reluctant to take out loans because they knew they wouldn't make enough profits to pay them back. This meant more businesses were going out of business and unemployment increased.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I Agree with Julia, Caitlin and some other students. I believe monetary causes were the main significant cause of the Great Depressing. I have swayed my view between both unequal distribution of wealth and monetary causes yet I believe the Federal Reserve Bank and the Gold Standard were too powerful in causing the Depression to say Monetary causes were not the cause. I also agree with Taylor and Dani, their will always be an unequal distribution of well, so you cannot say the main cause was a problem that happens all over the world and doesn't always cause depressions. Firstly, the gold standard, reconstructed after World WW1 contracted the money supplies after banking shocks. Also, with this many people began to doubt the bank, pulling their money out of stock and therefore hurting the circulation of money. The Gold Standard was put in place in order to cause inflation by not printing money; the belief in this decision was to increase trade. But this was a massive failure because by the 1920’s the gold standard had flooded the US, and we now held about 70% of the worlds supply of money, making prices around the would inflate. Soon, this led to low interest rates, which created a stock speculation, which later led to the government deciding to higher interest rates, which ultimately slowed down the economy and created the Great Depression.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I think the biggest proposed cause of the great depression that hits me the most is the decisions and policies of the Federal Reserve Bank. It is said that a nation's economy fluctuates constantly, and certain circumstances cause slight recessions in a certain period of years. Just like these normal recessions (when I say normal, I don't mean its a good thing), the Great Depression originated from one of these recessions. Sure, there were other causes that plummeted the economy into depression other than the Federal Reserve Bank, but the fact that the Federal Reserve Bank was supposed to but failed at keeping the economy on track during a recession and eventually bringing it back to it's former state is disturbing. For example, the I believe the Federal Reserve Bank was too closed to new ideas when they tried to maintain the Gold Standard too much. They fiddled with interest rates too much, which therefore caused a drop in the economy. They were also not the best decision makers when it came to dealing with helping banks. There can be much more said about the Federal Reserve Bank, but all in all I just really think that they were the key to either helping or destroying the economy. However, there may have been other factors or different mindsets of the time period that we cannot understand in the modern world that may have hindered their ability to make what we see as easy/simple decisions.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I, like a lot of other people, think the biggest cause of the great depression was the gold standard and the policies that were effected by it. Because the amount of gold dictates how much money was in the country, when gold flowed out, the US lost money and the government tried to balance that out. They raised interest rates so people would be more reluctant to borrow money. The policies the government used to counter-act the loss of gold led the U.S towards the Great Depression. Also, in the Ben Bernanke essay, he showed that countries with the gold standard had more recessions and depressions than countries without the gold standard.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Before starting this unit, I saw the Stock Crash and the Great Depression as one in the same but I could not be anymore wrong. I have learned quickly from our class discussions and lessons that the Stock Crash is a very minor cause of the Depression. In my opinion I think the runs on the banks are the greatest cause. I think this because when people started withdrawing all of their money because they thought the banks were going to run into the ground, the banks had to call in all their loans to pay back all of their depositers. When the money was taken out, this shrunk the money supply because people hid their money in their back yards and in their houses instead of putting it into the economy which is what the economy needed so badly at the time.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I think that the Federal Reserve Bank policy was a very important cause of the Great Depression. The fact that so many people lost their faith and trust in the banking system not only hurts economically, but socially as well. The fact that people would no longer keep their money in the safety of the bank, but under their mattresses or in coffee cans stopped the flow of money in the economy which also hurt and I think was one of the larger scale causes of the Great Depression. It is alot to not trust your governement, and it is even more when you can not trust the banking system where all your money is supposed to be kept safe and grow.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I still maintain that the gold standard was the primary cause for the depression. The gold standard caused an influx of money into the US, so interest rates were lowered to decrease the amount of money coming into the country, because it isn't good if one country has too much of the world's gold. The low interest rates caused speculation and buying stocks on margin. When stock prices dropped a little, people panicked and withdrew their money, causing a greater fall and money to flow out of the US. Around the same time, the Fed raised interest rates to try to keep the money from leaving the country. This caused an economic slowdown and the stock bubble to "burst." Gold was still leaving the country, so the Fed raised rates yet again, "turning the depression into the Great Depression."
    The gold standard is made stronger as a cause when it is considered that all countries on the standard experienced a depression, but were able to come out of it soon after leaving the gold standard. Even though countries not on the gold standard experienced depressions, the magnitude of the problem was not so large in those countries. Hence, there is a definite connection between the gold standard and economic distress. A reason why the gold standard did not cause a greater problem when it was introduced could be that at that time conditions were beneficial to the gold standard, and something in the 20s changed, making the gold standard a problem.

    ReplyDelete
  24. It seems from our reading of all the different historians take on the causes of the Depression, that in my opinion the best choice is Monetary Causes. Specifically, the polices of the Federal Reserve Bank. I do not believe it is trade, since trade in the US at the time was only 2-3% of our economy. In addition, unequal distribution of wealth does not seem as strong as the monetary causes since there will always be unequal distribution of wealth, unless we live in a completely Marxist/Communistic society. The Federal Reserve Bank, was given many chances to make the correct decision and keep us from going into a Depression. However, when government has bad decision making, history usually proves a dangerous outcome. In this case, a Depression. These bad decisions included raising interest rates, and not helping out the smaller banks that continuously were going bankrupt. Bad government economic policy can lead to things like a Depression, Stalin's Five-Year Plan was an example of this. The economy in Russia under communism actually seemed to be working at first, but it took a GOVERNMENT leader like Stalin to arise and create an immense amount of issues in Russia.

    -Aaron Haskell

    ReplyDelete
  25. I think that the strongest cause listed of the great depression was the Federal Reserve Bank policies/ the Gold Standard. The economy was in a recession which happens around every 20 years. A recession was not abnormal at the time, but the federal reserve bank turned the recession into a depression. They raised interest rates, to try to keep all of the gold in the U.S, but this slowed down the economy. The decision I think that made the Great Depression inevitable was the run on banks. By not saving the banks the public was affected . The U.S. lost complete faith in the banking system and many tired to withdraw money, public was in a panic. Because of all the withdrawals banks were not able to the people, business were left without money and this created high unemployment,
    -Kristen Adams C Block

    ReplyDelete
  26. I do not agree that the unequal distribution of wealth was the main cause of the depression. In all societies there are unequal distributions of wealth and most countries do not fall into a depression because of it. I think the single most important cause of the depression was the monetary causes (gold standard and Federal Reserve) were the main contributors of the Great Depression. We are always asked to as the question if this is the case then we would see.... and in asking the question we see that countries that had issues with the gold standard were hit with depression. In fact the countries that stayed on the gold standard the longest were hit hardest by the depression. With the amount of gold lessening in the U.S the amount of money we could produce to back it went down too. I think that the Federal Reserve was a cause of the depression because of there poor decisions regarding the gold standard. These poor decisions lead to nation wide panic and money taking money out of circulation and the banks, which lead to the depression

    -Cassandra Fibbe F block

    ReplyDelete
  27. I agree with everything that has been said so far. Before class today, I thought the main cause of the Depression was the unequal distribution of wealth but now I do not think it was that big of a cause. There is always unequal distribution of wealth no matter how well the economy is doing. I agree with Taylor that not all countries that have unequal distribution of wealth have gone into a depression therefore making this a weak cause.
    I also thought that the run on the banks and the failing of the banks were the most important causes of the depression. When people got scared due to the state of the economy, they took their money out of the banks. Taking their money out of the circulation caused the banks to start failing. We also saw this in Germany when the banks started to fail, the economy got worse and that led to a depression.

    ReplyDelete
  28. I completely agree with Julia that international trade and unequal distribution of wealth are contributing factors leading to the Great Depression but monetary problems (the gold standard and Federal Reserve Bank policies), was the main, most important cause. Like Julia said, the countries that had remained on the gold standard the longest had the longest depression and those countries that got off the gold standard the soonest got out of the depression the soonest. The poor decisions of the Federal Reserve that allowed the money supply to fall were also key components to the depression. The selling of dollars for gold (due to the gold standard) caused a run on the dollar. The Fed therefore raised interest rates to preserve the value of the dollar but this lowered the availability of money for businesses, causing more bankruptcies. As banks failed and consumer confidence was destroyed, the Federal Reserve did not increase the money supply to combat deflation. This slowing down of the economy is what caused the depression. It is not that this is the sole cause of the Great Depression, but it is the strongest.

    ReplyDelete
  29. After our class discussions, I have changed my mind regarding the strongest cause of the depression. I used to think that it was the unequal distribution of wealth because the upper class was putting large sums of money into business, which produced more supply, while the lower class had little money to create demand to counteract this supply. This in turn threw off balance in the economy. However, the wealth of the upper class only increased about 2% (from 24% to 26%, if I remember correctly), which doesn’t seem like an amount so substantial that it would affect business on such a large scale.

    Having looked at all the causes critically in class, I now feel that the most important cause of the depression was the gold standard. The gold standard was used heavily in the U.S. Seeing that it had such a strong economy and could therefore have a large percentage of gold in the world. This caused interest rates to go down, which in turn caused stock market speculation because lower interest rates meant that people could make profit off the stock market with borrowed money. I would assume that similar situations happened in other countries, because the countries that stayed on the gold standard the longest had the longest depressions while those that got off it the quickest had shorter depressions. However, I do not think that this cause is incredibly strong - if it were, I think we would have seen a depression much sooner seeing that the United States had already been on the gold standard for so long without seeing such a serious issue.

    ReplyDelete
  30. I believe that the Gold Standard led to the Great Depression. The United States, to prevent inflation and to make people feel their money was secure. However, in the 1920's to 1930's the US has 70% of the world's gold. That's a lot. Thus, other countries were buying gold in the US creating an influx of money. To slow that down, the US raised tariffs and interest rates. The Federal Reserve when faced with the problem about the gold standard thought that raising the interest rates would help the stop of Gold out of the country. However, they failed to expect a slowing of the economy that started the depression. Then, when faced with another decision the Federal Reserve raised the interest rates again which plunged the US into the worst depression it had ever seen. In conclusion, the United States use of the Gold Standard and the citizen's fear to let go of it, caused the federal reserve to increase interest rates which caused the depression in my opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  31. POST FOR PAT XU!!! His link isn't working.
    PAT SAYS:
    Among a few key causes of the Great Depression, the gold standard stands out as the most crucial. The gold standard, which maintained a certain ratio of printed money to gold, was designed to prevent inflation in the countries on it. In the United States, the Fed used interest rates to control the flow of gold; cutting interest rates helped gold flow out of the US, while increasing interest rates caused gold to flow into the US. However, the changing of interest rates had unintended consequences on the economy, aside from the control of gold.
    First, extremely low interest rates caused stock speculation, as people felt the incentive to purchase shares. The stock market rose artificially, otherwise known as a stock bubble. When the Fed tried to raise interest rates, the stock market crashed, and caused, at least what seemed to the people, to be great economic instability and uncertainty.
    Second, interest rates caused the shrinking of the money supply. In a time where deposits were not insured by the FDIC, people relied solely on the bank’s ability to stay open in order to keep their life-savings safe. When the economy took a turn for the worse, such as the 1929 stock crash, people began to withdraw large amounts of money from the banks, also known as a bank run. As only a small fraction of the deposited money is actually kept (most is invested by the bank, for example, as loans), and an increase in interest rates led to a shrinkage of the money supply, banks began to go bankrupt. Soon, people were losing their entire life savings. This plunged the country further into an economic depression. With people losing so much money, and businesses quickly found themselves unable to sell enough in order to stay afloat, going bankrupt. This quickly magnified until the country finally went off the gold standard, in 1933.
    -Pat Xu

    ReplyDelete
  32. I would like to start to dislike the idea that international trade would of caused the Great Depression. This was clearly shown in lesson 14 were there was a comment that the trade had only effected about 2%-3% of the GDP. This is clearly not a cause because if there was a decrease of 36% in GDP how could a fraction of that decrease cause it. I do believe that the international trade possible helped America reach such a big decrease in GDP but was not a main cause.
    The inequality of the wealth can be seen as a cause because of the problems that it created but yet i still don't believe that this could be the main cause. The inequality always exist so how could this cause something. This cause is like the gravity analogy Mr. O talks about yo.
    The best cause i see in this bunch is the gold standard/ FRB policies. These silly mistakes that the FRB makes just show how this huge decrease happened. They failed there own job by thinking that if you increase interest rates things will get better but it just hasn't worked yet. The increase in rates caused less spending which would lead to a decrease in GDP.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Christina Serpa
    F Block
    Along with others, I believe that the run on banks was one of the main causes of the Great Depression. The US government failed to notice these bank problems and help bail out the banks as well. Durning class discussions, this always seemed to come up as a huge factor and issue. The American public lost their faith in the banks and people everywhere withdrew their money. This caused major problems with not only the banking system, but the economy as well. Also, no one was taking out loans and interest rates rose because the economy was failing. More than half of the banks had to close down due to this issue and the American public was worried about their savings. The gold standard also was a main cause of the Great Depression because it caused major inflation and highered the interest rates as well but I feel that the run on banks had more links to the Great Depression in effecting it.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Peter Durgin

    Like the majority of people, I believe that monetary causes (such as the gold standard and the federal bank reserve) were the main causes of the depression. As a few people have stated (currently in reference to Dani Bloom), the unequal distribution of wealth does not appear to be the most important cause as that occurs all over the world, and there are many stable economies even with the unequal distribution. The fact that so many people lost their trust in the U.S banking system caused our economy to plumit. The more the people became frightened and removed their cash from the banks, the more our economy began to feel the impact.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Kerri Cauley F Block
    I believe that one of the main causes of the depression was the bank runs. The federal Reserve paid little attention to the already smaller failing banks and did nothing to bail them out when they needed it. When the banks did fail this caused wide spread loss of faith in the banking system as a whole and when people stopped putting money in banks ( they rather would keep it under a mattress or buried in the backyard) it pulled even more money out of the struggling economy. I also believe that the gold standard widely contributed to the Great Depression as well, seeing as countries that came of it first recovered quicker than countries that continued to have the gold standard.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Through the various class discussions as well as readings, I believe that the cause of the Great Depression could be gold standard. Since the gold standard had its own benefits, the benefits could also be seen as a weakness especially the inability to put more money in circulation to help the economy. However, something that I have commonly been seeing is the severe amounts of fear that the people in the United States had. This fear, though relatively general is a stronger cause for the Great Depression. Although there were variations the majority of the countries that fell into the Depression feared an extreme devaluing of their money and fear of banks doing under. This fear that was instilled by the people could be taken the wrong way. But through this fear people lost faith in the gold standard, the financial system and the banks. Therefore, the fear that the people felt was in fact the main cause while it does relate to the gold standard.

    ReplyDelete
  37. My opinions on the causes of the Great Depression are similar to Andrew's above. I am not convinced that the international trade and the US' relations with other countries played a large role in the Depression. While some international trade is necessary for economic evolution, there are plenty of countries during this time period and others where a country has done fine without significant international trade. The most important cause of the depression in my eyes was the use of the gold standard. As the government tried to retain this monetary system, there was increased stock market speculation and spending (which led to the crash) and a decrease in spending. These difficulties caused by the gold standard were reacted too poorly by the Fed which plunged the nation further into depression. If it had not been for the Fed's decisions to raise interest rates and not to insure the banks who were then crippled by bank runs.

    - Arthur Hayden F Block

    ReplyDelete
  38. I feel that monetary problems such as the gold standard and the Federal Reserve played the biggest rule. This is because I think that many of the other causes of the Great Depression stemmed off of decisions made by the Fed and the restrictions that were present because of the Gold Standard. For example, the Fed was responsible for an increase in interest rates, which lead to high unemployment, lower wages, and difficulty for companies to stay afloat. This therefore decrease demand, creating a surplus, and slowed production. The gold standard was becoming an outdated system as many countries were no longer on this standard, so this would cause problems with international trade where other nations could dictate their own prices but we had to stay on the gold standard. Therefore, these two caused many other situations so they are the main causes.

    ReplyDelete
  39. I agree with Dani, unequal distribution of wealth is not a good/important cause. Like she mentioned, unequal distribution of wealth occurs in most other countries. Almost every society has a privileged rich and a deprived poor. In these societies, why don’t we see more leading to a crushing depression? I can understand that it possibly added to the traumatizing size of the depression in the US, but I don’t really see it as THE reason why the US went into the depression. Personally, I think the only actual and important cause is the runs on the banks. The connection between the runs on the banks is much stronger than the unequal distribution of wealth.

    ReplyDelete
  40. I agree with what Hannah (and I am sure many others) said, that the Great Depression was mainly caused by the Fed's obsession with the gold standard and raising interest rates. While low interest rates caused the stock crash, the government went too far in the other way and turned what might have been a stock-crash-caused-recession into a full-out depression. The raising of interest rates (which stemmed from the Fed wanting to stay on the gold standard) led to some of the other causes which have been cited, such as the bank runs and the decrease in foreign trade. These things, caused by the underlying cause of the Federal Reserve raising interest rates, led to the depression in ways which I'm sure other people have explained very eloquently. An intriguing thing about the gold standard is that countries that got off the gold standard more quickly recovered from the depression more quickly, and vice versa. This makes sense as related to international trade, and perhaps shows that international trade might have been a more powerful underlying cause than the (oft-cited) 2-3% statistic indicates.

    ReplyDelete
  41. I think that monetary causes especially the federal reserve bank policies were the main causes of the Great Depression. The Federal reserve increased taxes when these should have been decreased causing less loaning from banks and a shrink in the money supply. decreased money supply leads to higher unemployment because business leaders are not able to pay all the employees. Because more and more people were fired, productivity dropped in many factories and industries. This eventually led to a decline in GDP. Decline in GDP and increase of unemployment are characteristic signs of a depression. The main purpose for increasing interest rates was to maintain the gold standard. All countries in Europe that went through a Depression were also trying to preserve their gold standard by keeping interest rates high.

    ReplyDelete
  42. At first I believed that the unequal distribution of income was the main cause of the Great Depression, but after the class discussion I now think that it was the monetary causes such as the gold standard and Federal Reserve Policies, that were the main cause. The Federal Reserve Banks made poor decisions that ultimately lead to the Great Depression. Instead of decreasing interest rates, the Federal Reserve Banks decided to increase them which lead to high unemployment rates and slowed down the economy. In class, we could not really think of any problems with this cause which is why I think it is the strongest cause of the Great Depression. The Federal Reserve Bank is what caused the recession to turn into a depression.

    ReplyDelete
  43. I don't think international trade was an important cause because it was such a small percentage of the total economy. There have been many times in U.S. history that international trade has declined and there weren't depressions at those times. Although it meant that some countries couldn't repay the money they owed us, it wouldn't have been a problem had it not been for the policies of the Federal Reserve, which caused banks to collapse, spreading fear and mistrust of the banking system and causing the recession to collapse into a depression.
    Secondly, I don't think unequal distribution of wealth was the real problem because again, there have been many times in U.S. history that the income gap has been just as large, but we did not have depressions then. One could argue that as of recently, the income gap has been just as large as it was in the 20's- yet our current recession has not turned into a depression.
    I believe that the policies of the federal reserve were the cause because they did not support the banks, which caused them to collapse, which made people lose faith in the banking system. This meant that they spent less money and didn't put their money in banks, shrinking the money supply and the economy and lowering demand, which lead to less production and thus more unemployment.

    ReplyDelete
  44. I agree with Meg, the Federal Reserve was the main cause of the Great Depression. The Federal Reserve was responsible for the gold standard, the money supply, and protecting the value of currency. The Federal Reserve made poor decisions that impacted the entire economy concerning the gold standard and letting the money supply shrink so much. The Federal Reserve also increased interest rates which people in a depression can not afford. This decision slowed down the economy and had a very negative impact on the people. The people also began to lose faith in the banking system even more as a result of poor decisions made by the Federal Reserve. I do think there are other strong causes and that the Great Depression can not be attributed to just one cause, but the Federal Reserve is the strongest of all the causes.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Though I had thought originally that the extremely unequal distribution of wealth was the most important cause, after class on Thursday, i changed my mind. There is always unequal distribution of wealth, so why aren't we in a depression all the time?
    I agree with Meg, that the Federal Reserve was the primary cause. Before the Great Depression, the Fed made some very poor decisions. By lowering interest rates, they allowed money to flow out of the economy. Then, by raising interest rates they discouraged loaning (which had also encouraged consumers to make purchases, increasing GDP) and shrunk the economy and GDP even more. This raised unemployment, and sent the nation into the Great Depression.
    Another significant cause of the depression was the crash of the stock market. The stock crash was similar to when a scammer gets caught in a ponsie scheme; everybody panicked and wanted to get there money from the banks, but it wasn't there because it had been loaned out to the next person. The stock crash caused a dramatic loss in faith in the banking system. People were afraid to put their money in the bank; instead they hid it in their houses. This caused the banks to fail, contributing to the Great Depression.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Along with many of my classmates that have already blogged I also believe that the Federal Reserve was the main cause of the Great Depression. Before our brief discussion in class I believed that the runs on banks were the main cause but in reality th Federal Reserves had more of a part since they did not fulfill the needs of the country. The fact that the the Feds pushed for the gold standard led to an increased interest rate that was not good for the United States. This is in turn imoacted the lives of many in a very negative way since they were losing money due to the fact that everyone was losing faith in the banks across the country. With this being said theunemployment rates began to rise and every person was in a bad situation.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Similar to most other posts, I do not believe unequal distribution of wealth or international trades are good causes. There has always been an unequal distribution of money, so it would be impossible to say this caused the depression. Also, the income the United States received from international trades were not large enough to significantly damage the economy in a way that would result in a depression.
    Initially I had thought that the main cause of the Great Depression was the run on the banks, but after reviewing the causes in class and reading some blog posts, I now see that it was the monetary causes (gold standard/Federal Reserve Bank policies). As Julia said, this cause seems to have no faults. If the monetary problems caused our depression, we should see similar patterns across the world, and we do. The countries that stayed on the gold standard the longest, remained in a depression the longest. The countries that got rid of the gold standard were able to get themselves out of the depressions. It seems that the gold standard also had influence over the Federal Reserve’s decisions; they raised interest rates in order to save the gold standard. As a result, the money supply shrank even further and the depression got worse. Overall, it is clear to see that the gold standard and Federal Reserve Bank policies were the main cause of the Great Depression.

    ReplyDelete
  48. There are many possible causes for the depression, but in my opinion, the gold standard was the most important cause of the great depression. In the 1920s when there was a booming economy and people were gambling in the moment, there were low interest rates which caused a large amount of money to flow into the US economy. Since the US could not keep up with all the inflow of money while gold was rushing out of the country, they raised interest rates in order to try to stop the outflow of gold. This rapidly decreased the economy, leaving for a large economic decline. This decline sent people into a panic, reluctant to spend their money which further hurt the economy. This then led to the stock crash, which the depression shortly followed.

    ReplyDelete
  49. This is Matt Vogus... he had trouble blogging

    Matt Vogus- H Block Blog

    At first, I thought that the stock market was one of the biggest causes of the Depression. But after a lot of class discussion, I realized that it was just an effect of the poor economy but did not directly lead to the Depression.In reality, it only made the Depression worse.
    After ,many class discussions, I believe that one of the main causes of the Depression was the gold standard. The Federal Reserve failed to keep the value of American currency which slowed the economy greatly. The money supply in the US shrunk, and interest rates went up as well but people were not able to pay them. Because of this, the Americans lost faith in banking which damaged the econpomy even more.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Similar to others, I originally thought that the stock market was the main cause-- after all, why would it not make sense that a decline in GDP and increase in unemployment as two direct effects of the failure of the stock market wouldn't lead to the Depression?
    However, after evaluating this on my own and in class, i think that the failure of the Fed. reserve really caused the depression. They were in charge of regulating currency and basically keeping the economy afloat, and ultimately failed to do so.Because they increased interest rates on the public, people couldnt pay them, and everyone suffered as a result. The public lost faith in the gov and banking system, making everything worse.
    Obviously there were multiple causes to the depression such as wealth inequality, the gold standard, etc, however I firmly think that this was the most prominent cause.

    ReplyDelete
  51. I also believed initially without much investigation that the stock market was the main cause of the Great Depression. However, after evaluating the causes I now believe that the distrust in banks, and the shrinkage of the money supply was the main cause of the Great Depression. Since the money supply shrank, and the people lost confidence in the government and the banks, they withdrew their money from the banks. This took a lot of money out of circulation and the banks were no longer able to loan out money. If the banks are not able to loan out money, people will not be spending and therefore there is a decrease in demand and production. This causes problems for businesses and results in no growth for the economy and a decrease in GDP.
    Along with this cause there were several other factors that contributed to the Great Depression, and together they resulted in disaster. However I believe this is the most important cause.

    ReplyDelete
  52. As many have stated above, I initially believed the primary cause of the Great Depression was the inequality of wealth between the rich and poor because I thought the economy relied too heavily on the wealthy. After reading many arguments and discussing it greatly in class, I now believe the main cause was the mistakes of the Federal Reserve. One major policy of the Federal Reserve that ended up going wrong was the fact that the Federal Reserve did not act to provide liquidity to banks who were suffering runs. Rather, they did the opposite and preceded the whole crisis by its own sudden contraction of the money supply. This created a money shortage which led to runs on banks. This directly related to people consuming less because they wanted to save money so they wouldn't want to spend money which led to a downfall in production and consumption. Overall, there were many different causes to the Great Depression but the mistake of the Federal Reserve was a major one.

    ReplyDelete
  53. As predictable as many of my responses have been I am going to say the main cause of the Great Depression are the monetary causes. First lets start with the Gold Standard, for many years it was working well enough for the US and it know failed. Why now? Every year the worlds population grows by a large percentage, and sadly for all of us gold bars do not. So eventually the Gold Standard would become impractical world economy. Sadly for the US this occurred when the US had very poor FED members. When The economy was heading into a recession due to people not buying enough due to a lack of funds. The FED decided to decrease money supply. Apparently they like deflation over inflation. this decision lead to an even worse recession which bordered on a depression. then the FED was brainstorming ways to avoid a worse situation and someone in the room said "lets do exactly what we did to get to this point in the first place" and everyone else said "that's a wonderful idea" and they decreased money supply again. Welcome to the Great Depression everyone.

    ReplyDelete
  54. I am in the same position as Kelly. At first I thought the cause of the Great Depression was the unequal distribution of wealth. This made sense as it would mean that the rich were investing so much that there was an overproduction, which meant that workers got layed-off and then would also stop consuming. However, during class on Thursday many people pointed out that there is always an unequal distribution of wealth and we're not always in a depression. Therefore, I still believe that this was a factor in the Great Depression, but more of a factor that worsened the depression, not started it. After the class discussions, I now that that the main cause was the gold standard. For me, the most convincing piece of evidence of this as a cause was that countries that stayed on the gold standard had longer/worse depressions than the countries that got off of the gold standard quickly. I also agree with Meg and the many other students that said the Federal Reserve's decisions fueled and worsened the depression. I do not believe that the Federal Reserve could have prevented the depression alone, but their decisions to alter the interests rates were wrong decisions made at the wrong time. Overall, I believe that the gold standard was the main cause of the depression.

    -Caroline Flores, H block

    ReplyDelete
  55. I agree with Caroline that the main cause of the Great Depression was the gold standard and the Federal Reserve. Depressions happen fairly frequently in the grand scheme of economies. What made this particular depression extremely bad? Although we had been on the gold standard for a while, the gold standard made the depression worse. The gold standard and the Federal Reserve may not have started the depression, but they created the GREAT depression. Countries that were also in depression and got off the gold standard, like Caroline said, had a shorter depression and they recovered quicker. The Federal Reserve decided to keep the US on the gold standard, which was a mistake. Also their actions in the hope of shortening the depression, such as shrinking the money supply, actually made the depression worse. In my opinion, the two main cause that caused a depression to become the Great Depression were the gold standard and the Federal Reserve.

    - Maddy Lanois

    ReplyDelete
  56. The main cause of the Great Depression was the actions of the federal government including the Federal Reserve’s decision to raise interest rates. A normal market economy has what is called a business cycle. In a business cycle there are periods of growth in the economy which peak and then are followed by recessions in the economy. Eventually the economy begins to grow again after a period of time. In 1929 the economy stumbled into a recession after the reduction of consumer spending in the economy. This in turn tightened up the money supply which in turn lowered GDP. This was a recession, in an effort to fix the money supply the Federal Reserve decided to raise interest rate, but this was the wrong thing to do because this further tightened up the money supply. This in turn led to consumers spending less which meant GDP fell even more and turned a normal recession into a Great Depression.

    ReplyDelete
  57. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  58. I agree with Maddy and have to disagree with Kevin. I think that the gold standard was the deepest cause of the Great Depression. The federal governments attempt to control the in take and keep gold in the US caused them to make the decisions that Kevin mentioned. The government could not find a way to both stop inflation and keep the percent of the money supply they wanted in the US. Therefore they choose to stick with the gold standard and attempt to keep gold in the country which was a very poor decision. These poor decisions forced by the gold standard forced what would have been another routine recession into the Great Depression. To summaries the gold standard was the root cause of the depression

    ReplyDelete
  59. I believe that monetary issues such as the gold standard, and the actions of the Federal Reserve, were the leading causes of the Great Depression. The gold standard is a great cause because other times in History, various other countries have been affected by the results of the gold standard. Countries such as France and Italy which also remained on the gold standard remained in depression for longer amounts of time, than countries such as Spain and Britain who removed themselves from the monetary system. The gold standard created off balances in wealth, and messed up the system of money used. The values of different amounts of money were always at question. The actions of the Federal Reserve also created big problems leading to the Depression, they raised interest rates in order to help the gold standard system. They also decreased the money supply, all of these actions created problems for the country leading to the Depression. There is a clear connection between the causes and effects, and so I believe that monetary issues were the greatest cause of the depression.

    ReplyDelete
  60. My appologies for the late response due to the fact that I did not blog before going away for vacation. This delay does not however change my opinion on the cause of the great depression. One of the topics that was heatedly discussed in class was the United States dependence on gold to uphold the gold standard. This meant that all us currencey represented a set amount of gold. The gold standard ensured that there would not be inflation or deflation because of the fact that all of the money had a set value. We were also presented with information in a reading that we did for homework I believe that stated that countries that stayed on the gold standard for a longer amount of time stayed in a state of depression longer. This suggests that there is a very close and important connection between the gold standard and the United States falling into a depression. We can see that although the gold standard helped in keeping the US dollar on top, it detracted from the overall economy of the nation which led to the depression.

    ReplyDelete